Syllabus · Innovation Territories Sprint

The method,
before the work.

Every sprint reads a brand through six cultural panels, works the evidence with the six frictions of the Curiosity Engine, and judges the candidates on a six-criterion scorecard. This page defines all of it: what each part asks, what a real finding looks like, and the way each one fails. Keep it open while you read an atlas.


The order of a run

Panels are where you look.
Frictions are what the engine does.
The scorecard decides.

Three parts, three jobs. A panel is a stratum of evidence, researched on its own, without knowing what the other panels found. A friction is a move that takes away the answer anyone would give, so the next answer is further out; the engine runs six of them on the panels' evidence and ends with at least ten candidates. The scorecard is a separate tool that judges those candidates the way an innovation committee judges any bet.

STEP 0
Desk research
Five layers, twelve queries, every finding graded. Then the obvious answer is written down and set aside.
STEP 1
Six panels
Six independent cultural reads, region-locked, sourced, run without coordinating.
STEP 2
Six frictions
The engine works the evidence and produces at least ten candidates, each with a written receipt.
STEP 3
The scorecard
Every candidate scored 0 to 3 on six criteria, killed ones included.
STEP 4
Three territories
Three bets that pass the gates, each strong in a different place, each with its own trade-offs.

The test of whether the method ran: delete the six panels. If a territory still stands, the panels were decoration for a decision already made.


Part one

The six cultural panels

Six strata of the same brief, each researched separately. Each one sits in one of the four places a diagnosis looks: the company, the category, the consumer and the culture. The point where two or three panels land on the same thing without having spoken is the territory's first proof.

PANEL 01 · CULTURE
Mythic Strata

Pre-modern myth, ritual and archetype sitting underneath the obvious symbols of the brief.

Asks
What older story is this product already inside, whether or not the brand knows it?
A real finding
Don Julio, Mexico. Fire as the act of creation runs through every major tradition, and Mexico carries one of the most charged versions of it. The agave goes into a pit and comes out changed.
Fails when
The myth is ornament. If the same paragraph would sit under any brand in the category, it is a library card, not a read.
PANEL 02 · CULTURE
Adjacent Behavior

What the neighbouring premium categories have already made normal for the same buyer.

Asks
What has the shelf next door already got permission to do?
A real finding
Fever-Tree, US. The adult, sober-optional, bittersweet sparkling drink has become the occasion itself, rather than the assistant to a spirit.
Fails when
It turns into a competitor list. Adjacent is about behaviour that has already been permitted, not about who else is on the shelf.
PANEL 03 · CONSUMER
Generational Tension

Where cohort wants split, and which cohort the brand will have to choose.

Asks
Which two groups want opposite things here, and what does picking one of them cost?
A real finding
Don Julio, US. The growth cohort is second and third generation, US-born, bicultural. The brand's work still addresses their parents' Mexico.
Fails when
It becomes a demographic profile. A description of a cohort is not a tension. Name the split and name the cost of choosing.
PANEL 04 · CATEGORY
Category Rules We Break

The conventions the brand has to refuse for the new thing to be born at all.

Asks
Which rule must die, and who will defend it?
A real finding
Fever-Tree. The mixer is priced, packaged and sold as the junior partner to a spirit. Decouple the two and the whole economics change.
Fails when
The rule named is one nobody defends any more. Killing a dying convention costs nothing, and costing nothing is the tell.
PANEL 05 · CULTURE
Outside Forces

Forces with no interest in the category that are reshaping who buys, why, and how.

Asks
Which force with no interest in this category is changing it anyway?
A real finding
Fever-Tree, US. The drinking occasion is pulling away from alcohol and from sweetness at the same time, driven by health and by cost, not by the drinks industry.
Fails when
The force is a headline with no route in. Trace the consequence of the consequence until it reaches the shelf, or drop it.
PANEL 06 · COMPANY
Latent Brand Materials

What the brand's own substrate encodes that the current marketing has buried.

Asks
What is already in the name, the object and the archive, unused and still legible?
A real finding
Fever-Tree. The name is the cinchona, the fever tree, the bark quinine comes from. The tonic was medicine before it was a mixer.
Fails when
It slides into heritage. A founding date is not latent material. Latent means present, unspent, and readable today.

Part two

The six frictions

A language model returns the most probable answer: the centre of everything already written on the subject. There is no setting for less probable. So the engine never asks for something creative; it takes away the answer it was about to give, and the next one down is further out. Six ways of doing that. Five are procedures with a track record older than any model, and each names where it comes from. One is ours.

Each friction runs as a written step in the run file. A move that leaves no written receipt does not fire.

FRICTION 01
Refuse the first answer

Write down the answer anyone would give, set it aside, and look for at least one direction that comes from a force outside the category, followed to the consequence of the consequence.

Comes from
The Socratic elenchus: the first confident answer is taken apart before another is allowed. Second-order thinking, after Howard Marks, follows each consequence to the next one.
Example
Netflix as a second-order beneficiary of broadband adoption, rather than as a better video shop than Blockbuster. The wave came from outside video rental.
Fails as
Trend listing. A named macro force with no path to the shelf is a slide, not a finding.
FRICTION 02
Excavate the meaning

The brand’s meaning is found inside the brand: the archive, the object and the word read literally, and the myth the product already sits inside.

Comes from
Roland Barthes, Mythologies (1957), reading what ordinary objects are already saying; marketing semiotics after Jean-Marie Floch.
Example
Burberry under Christopher Bailey from 2001, pulling the trench coat and the house check back to the centre. Coca-Cola, whose coca leaf and kola nut are printed in its own name.
Fails as
Nostalgia, a pun or a mythology lecture: a reading that changes nothing about what gets made.
FRICTION 03
Invert it

Flip the problem, the category convention and your own first reading. Refuse the rule the category runs on. And when two opposite truths both hold, keep both instead of choosing.

Comes from
Falsification, and Rory Sutherland’s Alchemy after Niels Bohr. Holding both poles departs from Roger Martin’s The Opposable Mind (2007), which resolves the tension into a third idea; we keep it open.
Example
Liquid Death refusing wellness language to sell canned water. Patagonia running a commercial business at scale next to “Don’t Buy This Jacket”.
Fails as
Contrarianism, or compromise. A flip that cannot be grounded is a party trick; holding a tension is not averaging two positions.
FRICTION 04
Steal across domains

Borrow structure from another field: a behaviour the category next door already allows, a subculture, a book, a ritual, the way people talk online right now.

Comes from
Arthur Koestler, The Act of Creation (1964): bisociation, the new idea born where two fields that never met collide. Holt and Cameron’s source material for where brands borrow from.
Example
Streetwear into luxury: Supreme with Louis Vuitton in 2017, Virgil Abloh at Louis Vuitton Men’s in 2018.
Fails as
A borrowing that matches on looks and fails on mechanism, or a co-branding idea in place of a borrowed behaviour. The mechanism is written in words from neither field.
FRICTION 05
Impose a constraint

Take a tool out of the hand and solve the problem anyway. The cut falls on what the obvious answers lean on, chosen so its absence says something about the diagnosis.

Comes from
OuLiPo. Georges Perec wrote La Disparition (1969) without the letter E, the most common letter in French, in a novel about a disappearance.
Example
No paid media, for a brand that drops out of view whenever its advertising stops. The same cut on another brief would be decoration.
Fails as
A generic rule. If the constraint would make sense on any brief, or the answer was reachable without it, it did no work.
FRICTION 06
Build a world

Move the ground instead of the answer: build a world with its own rules and ask for its paperwork, a job listing or a statute, never for ideas.

Comes from
Ours, with no borrowed procedure behind it. A built world invents by design, so the provenance tags are checked hardest right after this step.
What it does
The improbable answer from here becomes the probable answer from inside the built world. The reading is carried back, tagged as fiction.
Fails as
A story. A world that delivers a narrative instead of a reading carried back is entertainment.

Part three

How the scorecard works

The frictions produce at least ten candidates. The scorecard decides which are worth a bet. It is built from the standard innovation screens: desirable, viable, feasible (IDEO; Tim Brown, Change by Design, 2009), with the questions from George Day’s “Is It Real? Can We Win? Is It Worth Doing?” (Harvard Business Review, 2007), plus one column from the engine.

Every candidate is scored, killed ones included. Each criterion goes from 0 to 3, and every score carries its evidence and its tag. A score with no evidence is a 0.

The six scorecard criteria, with what a 0 and a 3 look like
Criterion LensThe questionA 0A 3
Felt tensionDesirableDo people already feel this?It tells people a factPeople already carry it and cannot yet say it
Size of the prizeViableIs the market real, and how big?No market logicA sourced figure plus a plausible slice
Open spaceViableWho is already there, and why is it free?Rivals already do itOpen, with the reason it is empty
Worth doingViableDoes the money work?No price or margin logicPrice and margin source named
Right to winFeasibleCan this brand say it, and can the company make and sell it?Nothing ties it to the brandA brand asset and a capability, both evidenced
DistanceEngineHow far is it from the answer anyone would give?It is the obvious answerFar from it, measured

Two marks travel with every score: the horizon (H1, H2, H3, after Baghai, Coley and White, 1999) and the moment of the tension (residual, dominant or emergent, after Raymond Williams, 1977).

GATE 01
Distance

Three clean answers to the brief, asked straight, are generated before any friction runs. A candidate that a separate judge model reads as one of them does not ship without a written reason.

GATE 02
Delete the panels

Remove the six panel readings from the run. A territory that still stands came from the news or the market data, and was decided before the cultural work began.

GATE 03
No total

The scorecard is a profile, never a sum. Market size and margin are estimates at this stage and never kill a candidate before the business case is built.

Three territories ship side by side, each from a different friction, each strong in a different place. The killed candidates are shown with the reason they died, because the best idea in a run is sometimes in the killed pile.


Part four

Two rules that govern every finding

The panels and the frictions produce claims. Two rules decide whether a claim is allowed to carry weight in the deliverable.

Provenance

SOURCED
A real, traceable reference. Ships as a fact.
INFERRED
Synthesis of sourced material. Ships as a pattern, labelled as one.
HYPOTHESIZED
Strategic imagination. Ships as a leap, marked as a leap.

A claim that fits none of the three does not ship.

Region lock

The brief locks one geography, and every cultural and consumer source has to come from it. A sprint locked on the United States cannot prove a US territory with a UK statistic, even when the underlying pattern is real everywhere. Company-level facts are the one exception, because they are facts about the brand rather than about the locked market.

See the method
on a real brand.

Read the Don Julio atlas